The teacher was going over study guide questions for Of Mice and Men with the students for a test they were going to have today. She did a good job of encouraging class involvement by having students answer the questions aloud without having to raise their hands. Although it was a bit chaotic, at least she was able to hold their attention.
The thing that shocked me about the way she managed her class is that she allows the students to play on their cell phones or listen to their iPods at any time during class, as long as they do so discretely and non-disruptively. Her one stipulation is that those students or their parents should not come to her at the end of the semester asking how they can improve their grades.
While I was initially skeptical of her for allowing that kind of behavior, I recognized how brilliant the idea was. She had obviously struggled to promote self-efficacy in the students at the beginning of the semester, but the students refused to take charge of their own learning. Instead of babying them every step of the way, which surely would have cost this teacher her sanity, she put things in the hands of the students. She still taught the material in the same way she would have, but she didn't stop to make sure that the distracted students were keeping up. She put the responsibility on the students to either earn the grades they want or accept the consequences of goofing off every day.
Her libertarian styles reminded me almost of a college professor. A professor's job is to present the material; a college student's job is to learn the material. Typically, a high school teacher's job extends far beyond simply presenting the material; she should work every step of the way to facilitate students' learning. However, this only works up to a point. It is possible, as evidenced by this classroom, that some students really are beyond the help of the teacher. No amount of teaching will get these students to learn if they truly don't want to. While I initially diagnosed her teaching methods as a sign of survival mode, I now realize that this teacher was doing the best she could for herself and her students.








